|
April 2, 2003An Exchange of Viewsby Joe Katzman at April 2, 2003 8:28 PM
Winds of Change.NET reader and loyal correspondent Tom Donelson passes on this email from a friend in Washington, D.C.: "To nobodys surprise there were protestors today in DC, they attempted to disrupt the metro system and block the Key Bridge, a leading artery into DC from Northern Virginia. I got hosed twice because I come in from NoVA on the metro and it is raining hard which makes traffic worse any way. My commute was long and arduous and only caused further resentment for protestors... Anyway, I'll get to the point.Yes, there are well-intentioned people on the other side of this debate. Still, I'm with James Lileks when he wrote: "To be honest, though: lately I say this more out of habit than conviction. It's become something I feel obligated to say, because I do want to make a distinction between the sensible dissenters and the moral cripples who superimpose Bush's face on bin Laden's head and proclaim the president the real terrorist. But the dissenters' arguments grow thinner every day."Those out demonstrating against the war at this point aren't the sensible types, or well intentioned. Glad to see people calling them on it. Tracked: April 2, 2003 11:01 PM
Getting Your Protest On from marcusblog
Excerpt: As I've written before, I don't have a problem with the idea of war protestors. In fact, I think most...
Tracked: April 3, 2003 5:21 AM
Demonstration story from The Inscrutable American
Excerpt: Winds of Change has an email with a story about an exchange (verbal) between an anti-war demonstrator and aan old...
Tracked: April 4, 2003 12:38 AM
An exchange of opinion about the war in Iraq from Low Earth Orbit
Excerpt: A story from the Washington DC subway [source]An elderly woman was behind me getting off the escalator and a young...
Tracked: April 4, 2003 1:38 PM
Glad That's Over... from Sgt. Stryker's Daily Briefing
Excerpt: Looks Stryker and I have similar problems. I had to go out of town on short notice, and when I got back this morning I discovered almost 200 messages in my inbox... Mean while, check out this exchange of views Joe posted on WindsOfChange....
Tracked: April 4, 2003 7:19 PM
Exchanging views from Bill Kearney
Excerpt: Apparently DC commuters aren't afraid to voice their opinions with ill-informed pseudo-protesters.
"...if you touch me again, I'll stick this umbrella up your ass and open it."
Comments
#1 from KL duPre' at 10:36 pm on Apr 02, 2003
Thanks for sharing! Wish I had heard it with my own ears. Has anyone read Nat Hentoff's [Why I am not marching against the war] in the Village Voice online? Can't link to it, but hope you'll find it and read it. Today has been a really good day to Blog! Thanks for adding to my reading and thinking pleasure. Here's the link to the Hentoff article on why he's not marching in anti-war protests this time around.
#3 from bkw at 5:45 pm on Apr 03, 2003
i'd argue that those still protesting the war are less about protesting the war and more about protesting bush.
#4 from Yves at 2:02 pm on Apr 04, 2003
I was reading the other,day about Pearl Jam in concert. These woosy Bas.... would be the first ones to run and hide if the war was in the US. I believe we should still have the draft, then these anti-Bush, anti-War babies would see what it is like when you walk into a country that has been run by Dictators for so many years.They can sit back in their fancy homes and wine about the war until its on their doorstep, then they'll be protesting that the Government is ignoring them if the soldiers don't show up in time. To all you protesters against this war. GROW UP AND GET A LIFE.
#5 from Peter at 3:39 pm on Apr 04, 2003
The patriotic left died with Hubert Humphrey, Scoop Jackson and Daniel Patrick Moynahan.
#6 from ardsgaine at 4:00 pm on Apr 04, 2003
There's a very easy way to separate the sensible dissenter from the moral cripple. A sensible dissenter is one who recognizes the essential moral virtue of the US and wants the best for this country. He might have thought that the war was not in the best intersts of the US, but now that the shooting has started, the sensible dissenter recognizes that the only good way for it to end is with a US victory. He knows that simply walking out and leaving Saddam in power is not an option. Hence, no one who is still protesting, trying to end the war, can be considered a sensible dissenter. Those who are still protesting fall into one of two possible categories: 1) those who hate the USA and everything it stands for; and 2) those who just hate Bush. I'm not certain that those really are two categories, but I allow for the possibility that there might be people whose hatred for Bush is so deeply ingrained that they are blind to the fact that, in trying to bring him down by making the war a political issue, they are doing our country a grave disservice.
#7 from Sabrina at 4:32 pm on Apr 04, 2003
I SUpport in ITALY the troops... Great story. I'm against the war, but I loathe the "don't you care about the children in (fill in the blank)" line that big-L Liberals have used as a red-herring for every single conflict we've been in since at least the beginning of the Reagan administration. I do not consider myself a Liberal. I consider myself a patriot. I served in the military, and I even voted once for a previous Bush. I never voted for Clinton or Gore. But I think the war is wrong. Still, if someone had used the "don't you care" line on me (which, when I was in college, usually was followed by "the children in Nicaragua"), I probably would have reacted similarly. You don't create informed dissent by accusing your audience of not caring, or by "dying" in front of their cab, or by burning the flag. The only way to achieve change is by a rational exchange of ideas; anybody who uses the "don't you care" argument isn't intellectually invested enough in the debate to be worth listening to. It's something of a commentary on our time that: Since Black Tuesday, the in-your-face anti-American Left is getting whacked in the teeth this way more frequently than before. Still not frequently enough, but one must start somewhere.
#10 from jerryluvsjazz at 11:10 pm on Apr 04, 2003
I'm a recently new blogger and felt like contributing to this wonderfully enticing dialogue. I'm a liberal and I'm ashamed of the conduct that other liberals are displaying. I'm also a veteran and have a deep sense of patriotism towards my country and fellow citizens. The "Left" that everyone is speaking of is truly disrepresentative of my thinking and judgement regarding this war. While I don't agree with the manner our government has approached this war, I do agree that the action is necessary. I couldn't agree more with ardsgaine and sean g! If you are a dissenter, you have the right to an opinion, but recognize that a difference of opinion should minimally require a different solution; lacking a proposed solution makes you nothing more than a whining idiot.
#11 from Jeffery at 4:36 am on Apr 06, 2003
It is an impressive new fighting force that we have put into action in Iraq and the technology is not perfect but it is an order of magnitude better than anything previously seen in use to limit civilian deaths. I didn't want this to happen and feel that our current leaders decided to put their peace plan for the region into action no matter how many American's told them no. They lied to us right and left to confuse the real motives that are behind their actions and I'm not ok with that. But I'll admit that the reality of becoming the world's police force and cooling down these troubled areas is one I can understand and agree with. Anyone who drives their car to protest this war looses all credibility in my eyes because you can't have one without the other. I support our brave military men and women 100% and say good job people. I regret that protesting the lies our leaders have used to put these soldiers in harms way will soon be punishable as an act of terrorism as our basic freedoms of speech and assembly are removed. Considering the actions of many of these future terrorists there will be few mourning their incarceration nor realizing the cost we as Americans will pay for the false promise of safety offered in exchange for those rights.
#12 from Eric Rolph at 5:44 pm on Apr 06, 2003
Stereotyping from any side of debate or discussion does nothing to further a positive discussion about divisive issues. On, the otherhand, I feel stereotypes lend well to isolation and contempt. Sometimes I like to isolate myself because of the overwhelming failures I witness in others attempts to create peace, undestanding, and mutual accord. And in that way, I might say, "You fucking idiots." Leave it up to yourself whom I might be directing that statement toward.
#13 from Phil Weber at 6:18 pm on Apr 07, 2003
So the old lady doesn't even seem to understand the cause for which her husband died. That's truly a shame. I'm so tired of hearing that those who are protesting are unpatriotic or -- as I was called yesterday -- "parasites of freedom." The fact of the matter is, though I am a pacifist, I would have hopped a plane to Afghanistan to shoot bin Laden myself -- and I would have slept like a baby afterward -- if I had had the chance. That's because he was a real threat. But Saddam has never been a threat to the US. After two weeks of war there are still no chemical or bio weapons. (Sure, we may eventually find them, but they certainly don't seem to be pervasive). There is even some evidence that the Bush administration forged documents to make it look like Iraq had a nuclear program -- and there is positively zero evidence of any such weapons. Osama bin Laden only became interested in bringing down the US after what he perceived as meddling in Arab affairs in Gulf War I. So now that we are back -- with no UN mandate and in opposition to world opinion -- how many new bin Ladens are we creating? When I protest this war I do so because the President, who had never been off the continent before his election, is a fool with no understanding of the world around him. I am protesting to keep our troops home and all of us safe from more terror. Let's address actual threats: North Korea and the remnants of al Qaeda, not some ficticious enemy that the CEO-in-chief has concocted.
#14 from wmscott at 12:08 am on Apr 08, 2003
This was written by Teddy Roosevelt and printed on the inside cover of the bible biven to every American Soldier as they left ot liberate Europe in WWI. The teaching of the New Testament is foreshadowed in Micah’s verse: “What more doth the Lord require of thee than to do justice, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God.” Do justice; and therefore fight valiantly against those that stand for the reign of Moloch and Beelzebub on this earth. Love mercy; treat your enemies well; succor the afflicted; treat every woman as if she were your sister; care for the little children; and be tender with the old and helpless. Walk humbly; you will do so if you study the life and teachings of the Savior, walking in His steps. And remember: the most perfect machinery of government will not keep us as a nation from destruction if there is not within us a soul. No abounding of material prosperity shall avail us if our spiritual senses atrophy. The foes of our own household will surely prevail against us unless there be in our people an inner life which finds its outward expression in a morality like unto that preached by the seers and prophets of God when the grandeur that was Greece and the glory that was Rome still lay in the future. I believe we are seeing this wish put into action by our soldiers now. I am very proud of them all!
#15 from chris at 6:05 am on Apr 08, 2003
Since when is criticing the current adminstration "bad-mouthing" America? There's huge leap there. I don't think the Founding Fathers would have drafted the Bill of Rights if they didn't believe voicing opinions about how the nation's resources was one of the foundations of democracy. I hope that woman's husband is mortally ashamed of her, since she's expressing a sentiment - discouraging someone from speaking their mind about the government - that is far, far more anti-American than anything I've seen at an anti-war demonstration. Ardsgaine's comment about the distinction between "the sensible dissenter from the moral cripple" strikes me as profound and true. If you believe it, and I do, then yes this protester is going beyond bad mouthing an administration - she is indeed expressing hostility to the country, not just its present steward. The creeping perception that this is in fact the "peace" movement's animating principle above all others does much to explain both the elderly lady's reaction in this instance, and the growing marginalization of the Left in the United States.
#17 from chris at 7:09 am on Apr 08, 2003
how is that expressing hostility to America? Bush is only one American. A powerful American, but he does not represent America, particularly within these borders where we are free to criticize our leaders.
#18 from chris at 7:10 am on Apr 08, 2003
As a Christian, I think anyone who uses the bible to support this war is a moral cripple. If you want to pervert a sacred text in the name of violence and quash dissidence you belong in a nation like Iran.
#19 from Wondering at 6:09 pm on Apr 08, 2003
Does anyone really believe this story? It screams "phony" to me. As someone familiar with the concept of Christian "just war" doctrine, I find the position of "Christians" like chris to be profoundly ironic, in 2 ways. [1] Advocating a religious position that does not in fact exist - the Bible could indeed be used legitimately by a believing Christian to justify war, so perhaps closer study of his religion would be beneficial; and [2] He suggests Iran as a suitable place for his political opponents, but the gravitas of his argument against them is theological. Uh, chris, I think that's their game, not ours. Church, state... no? Never mind. If you convert to Islam, chris, I think the Iranians will happily take you.
Post a comment
Here are some quick tips for adding simple Textile formatting to your comments, though you can also use proper HTML tags: |
You're Reading an Individual Post!
If you want to head to the main blog page, just follow the "Main" link in the navigation up top underneath our blog's name. Or click here:
Winds of Change.NET Home
Winds of Change Library
Support VictoryPAC
Recent Entries
· Aristotle and the Ten Second Problem: Free Will and the Martial Arts
· The Gift That Keeps On Giving - Yglesias Regretting The American Revolution · Free Ice Cream News · The Road to Kosovo, Part II · Letting The Gun Manufacturers Solve The Gun Violence Problem - Why Not? · Unbreakable You · The Iraqification of Lebanon · There's No Word For This Except "Stupid". · How Kosovo Created its Own Liberal Islam · In Case You Wonder Why Obama's Position On Iraq Is "Nuanced" · No Peace in Lebanon · Expectations · Who Knew Segways Were Useful? · This Is Cool In Several Ways · The Road to Kosovo, Part I
Support Winds of Change.NET!
Your support & assistance is greatly appreciated, and makes a difference!
The Winds Crew:
Town Founder: Joe Katzman joe {at} windsofchange. net Joe's Normblog Interview Left-Hand Man: Marc 'Armed Liberal' Danziger armed {at} windsofchange. net A.L.'s Normblog Interview Other Winds Marshals 'AMac', aka. Marshal Festus (AMac@...) Robin "Straight Shooter" Burk 'Cicero', aka. The Quiet Man (cicero@...) David Blue (david.blue@...) 'Lewy14', aka. Marshal Leroy (lewy14@...) 'Nortius Maximus', aka. Big Tuna (nortius.maximus@...) Other Regulars 'Callimachus' (callimachus@...) 'Demosophist' (demosophist@...) Rev./Maj. Donald Sensing 'Molon Labe' (molon.labe@...) 'Neo Neo-Con' Tarek Heggy (tarek@...) Semi-Active: Arthur Chrenkoff 'Gabriel Gonzalez' (in Paris) Tim Oren (tim@...) Trent Telenko (trent@...) Posting Affiliates Athena: Terrorism Unveiled Chester: The Adventures of Chester Dave Schuler: The Glittering Eye Grim: Grim's Lair et. al. Joel Gaines [Russia] Michael Totten MILblogging.com: The MilBlogs directory Murdoc [Military] Situational Awareness team [Military] Nathan Hamm [Central Asia] Randy Paul [Latin America] Robert Koehler [Koreas] Robi Sen [India & S. Asia] Nitin Pai [India & S. Asia] Simon [China & E. Asia] Yehudit: Kesher Talk Regular Topic Briefings: Andrew Olmsted [Iraq Weekly] Joel Gaines [Iraq Weekly] Security Watchtower [GWoT Mon.] Peace Like A River [GWoT Mon.] Colt [GWoT Thu.] John Atkinson [Alternative Energy] Peter Wolfgang [Alternative Energy] Omri Ceren [Hatewatch] Emeritus: Adil Farooq (adil@...) Celeste Bilby (celeste@...) Dan Darling Gary Farber (gary@...) Hossein Derakhshan (hoder@...) T.L. James (tljames@...) Robin Burk (robin@...)
Winds of Change.NET Blogkids & Affiliates
· The Argus: covering Central Asia · Canis Iratus: Glen Wishard · Correct-Amundo: Tech & society · Discarded Lies: Ev & Zorkie · The Flying Kiwi: Donovan Janus · The Glittering Eye: Dave Schuler · Gumptionology: Nortius Maximus · Hot Needle of Inquiry: 'Jinnderella' · Laughing Wolf: C. Blake Powers · Out The Mazoo: 'Mazoo' · Power and Control: M. Simon · Praktike's Place: 'Praktike' · Random Probabilities: Robin Burk · Siberian Light: covering Russia · The Spirit of Man · Good News From the Front · WATCH/: covering the war on terror
Archives By Category
-FEATURES: 48 Ways to Wisdom (24)
-FEATURES: Diaries & Roundups (10) -FEATURES: Military Transformation Uplink (12) -FEATURES: New Energy Currents (20) -FEATURES: Reader Highlights (2) -FEATURES: Regional Briefings (166) -FEATURES: Sufi Wisdom (158) -FEATURES: The Bard's Breath (32) -FEATURES: Winds of Discovery (6) -FEATURES: Winds of War [WoT] (444) 4 HA: 4th-Gen Warfare (102) 4 HA: al-Qaeda (159) 4 HA: Crime, Organized (26) 4 HA: Evil Exists (110) 4 HA: Intelligence/Spycraft (100) 4 HA: Military (520) 4 HA: Nukes, Poisons, Germs (135) 4 HA: Statecraft (29) 4 HA: War on Terror articles (706) Best Of... (179) BIZ: Business & Organizations (130) BIZ: Economics (95) BIZ: Energy (70) CIVIS (230) CIVIS: Copyright Wars (25) CIVIS: Drug Wars (18) CIVIS: Edu-Kooks (76) CIVIS: Free Societies (284) CIVIS: Hall of Shame (162) CIVIS: Hatred Rising (114) CIVIS: Journalism & Media (396) CIVIS: Spirit of America.NET (31) CIVIS: War Within the West (309) COLUMNISTS: M. Simon (13) COLUMNISTS: Tarek Heggy (33) GEO: Afghanistan (78) GEO: Africa (101) GEO: Asia (116) GEO: Aussies & Kiwis (20) GEO: Canada (68) GEO: China (86) GEO: Europe (176) GEO: France (71) GEO: India-Pakistan (112) GEO: Iran (223) GEO: Iraq (956) GEO: Israel (245) GEO: Koreas (64) GEO: Latin America (63) GEO: Middle East (254) GEO: Russia (74) GEO: Saudi Arabia (64) GEO: Sudan (36) GEO: U.K. (70) GEO: U.N. (60) GEO: U.S. of A (502) HUMANITY (88) HUMANITY: Art & Culture (157) HUMANITY: Art - Music (32) HUMANITY: Art - Poetry (6) HUMANITY: Christianity (52) HUMANITY: Heroes & Achievements (228) HUMANITY: History (124) HUMANITY: Islam (182) HUMANITY: Judaism (136) HUMANITY: Love (32) HUMANITY: Philosophy (48) HUMANITY: Spirituality & Religion (72) HUMANITY: Zen & Buddhism (28) Humour (194) Misc. (42) NET: Blogosphere (390) NET: Cyber-Security (16) NET: Grid Computing (3) NET: Spam (24) NET: The Internet (35) NET: The Open Source Meme (17) Personal (186) SCI-TECH: Biotech & Medical (83) SCI-TECH: Eco-tech (81) SCI-TECH: Nanotech (27) SCI-TECH: Science (111) SCI-TECH: Space (75) SCI-TECH: Technology (143) SPORTS (45) SPORTS: Baseball (75) Trends (64) USA: America Catch-all (19) USA: Anti-Americanism (6) USA: California Politics (4) USA: Conservatives & GOP (31) USA: Dem Party Renewal (70) USA: Domestic Issues (50) USA: Elections (83) USA: Grand Strategy (15) USA: Homeland Security (105) VictoryPAC (3) Winds of Change.NET (49)
Archives by Date
July 2008
June 2008 May 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 September 2007 August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004 December 2003 November 2003 October 2003 September 2003 August 2003 July 2003 June 2003 May 2003 April 2003 March 2003 February 2003 January 2003 November 2002 October 2002 September 2002 August 2002 July 2002 June 2002 May 2002 April 2002 Joe's Old Archives, By Title: April - June 2002 July - December 2002
Winds Blogroll
Top Prospects
Support VictoryPACSP Normblog (LHP) SP Solomonia (RHP) RF Mader Blog CF Donklephant LF Harry's Place C Critical Mass 1B Tigerhawk 2B Gideon's Blog SS Alexander the Average 3B Democracy Arsenal UT INF Pundita DH Counterterrorism Blog PEN Liberals Against Terrorism CL Gates of Vienna MASCOT Huffington's Toast MGR Robert Tagorda GM Conservative Grapevine Humour Blogs · Cox & Forkum (cartoons) · Day By Day (cartoons) · User Friendly (cartoons) · AllahPundit (satire) · Scrappleface (satire) Religious Blogs · Conscientia (baha'i) · Unlearned Hand (bud) · Eve Tushnet (cath) · Muslim Under Progress (isl) · Ideofact (isl) · Kesher Talk (jew) · Rabbi Lazer Brody (jew) · Rishon Rishon (jew) · Rev. Donald Sensing (prot) Other Team Memberships · Command Post [All] · No End But Victory [All] · AlwaysOn [JK] Blog Services · NZ Bear's Ecosystem · Blogstreet · Daypop Top 40 · Technorati · Movable Type.org · Write A Better Blog More entries coming! |
http://www.windsofchange.net/windsopcentre-cms/trackback.cgi/1034
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference
"An Exchange of Views"