Winds of Change.NET: Liberty. Discovery. Humanity. Victory.


Formal Affiliations

Anti-Idiotarian Manifesto
Euston Democratic Progressive Manifesto
Real Democracy for Iran!
Support Denamrk
Million Voices for Darfur
milblogs
Prev | List | Random | Next | Join
Powered by RingSurf!

e-Syndication

May 1, 2003

Conspiracies & Memetic Epidemics

by Joe Katzman at May 1, 2003 8:55 AM

Conspiracy theories and how to combat them were a big topic here last week, right on the heels of Dean Esmay's major contribution with his post about conspiracy theories generally. Well, here's a model that may help us get a handle on them: memetic epidemics.

meme: (pron. 'meem') A contagious information pattern that replicates by parasitically infecting human minds and altering their behavior, causing them to pass on the pattern. (Term coined by Dawkins, by analogy with "gene".) Individual slogans, catch-phrases, melodies, icons, inventions, and fashions are typical memes. An idea or information pattern is not a meme until it causes someone to replicate it, to repeat it to someone else. All transmitted knowledge is memetic.
Couple that concept with epidemic spread patterns and mechanisms, and we have a useful framework that also suggests counter-strategies. Here's how it all fits...

Some societies are indeed more predisposed to this behaviour than others, and conspiracy theories have a more "contagious" environment there. There's also a societal correction factor, which we might define as the "immune response capability." Call it the "Fisk Factor." When contagiousness in an environment is high and immune responses are low, conspiracy memes can and do go epidemic quickly. For a whole host of historical and cultural-political reasons, Arab/Islamic culture is a good example.

Simple enough. To fight these epidemics, however, we need to understand how they spread.

Malcolm Gladwell may have handed us the key. Fortunately, most members of a society are really passive players in this little drama. As he notes in his book "The Tipping Point" and in some of his articles, the people who really matter are a sequence of:

  • Mavens: Experts with credibility, who can communicate with laypeople;

  • Connectors: The folks who just seem to know everybody. They take the Mavens' memes and quickly spread them widely within and among social groups; and/or

  • Salesmen: Master convincers. You can interfere with any of these nodes to stop a meme, or leverage them instead to spread other memes. You also have the choice of attacking contagious environments directly (just as we drain standing puddles to remove mosquitoes), and/or building response and immunity capabilities (just as we use vaccinations and/or a system of readily available counter-medications) in a population.

    If we think in terms of these players and approaches, a number of potential strategies and approaches open up. Give it some thought, and I'm sure you can come up with a few of your own - or fit examples you've seen into this pattern.

    UPDATE: Lazypundit has an excellent point in this post's Comments section re: where satire fits into this framework.


  • TrackBack URL for this entry:
    http://www.windsofchange.net/windsopcentre-cms/trackback.cgi/1140

    Listed below are links to weblogs that reference
    "Conspiracies & Memetic Epidemics"
    Tracked: May 5, 2003 3:04 PM
    Chris Muir On Conspiracies from Dean's World
    Excerpt: Chris Muir, of Day By Day fame, has created a special editorial cartoon exclusively for Dean's World! It is inspired by my earlier article on...

    Comments
    #1 from Kevin Shaum at 10:30 am on May 01, 2003

    Immune response to a virus can be stimulated by innoculating the subject with a weakened form of the virus, a sample that has been killed or chemically altered so that it is not a threat. Yet the virus remains identifiable, the body learns to produce antibodies, and the immune response is engaged whenever the real viral agent is encountered.

    The memetic equivalent to this is obvious: satire. The target meme is rendered inoffensive through hyperbole or paradox, and potential hosts are innoculated with the neutered meme. Their immune response (skepticism, ridicule) is thereby developed, and comes into play whenever the original meme is encountered.

    So Scott Ott, Chris Muir, and Cox and Forkum are actually the best anti-Idiotarian memetic engineers we have.

    #2 from Joe Katzman at 4:53 pm on May 01, 2003

    That's a very intelligent point. Thanks, Kevin!

    #3 from Dean Esmay at 7:10 pm on May 01, 2003

    I'll second that motion. Well put indeed, Kevin!

    In fact, speaking of Chris Muir, tomorrow on my blog I'll be featuring a cartoon by him that examines this very theme!

    Entirely by coincidence, of course. Or so I'd have you believe....

    Post a comment

    Here are some quick tips for adding simple Textile formatting to your comments, though you can also use proper HTML tags:

    *This* puts text in bold.

    _This_ puts text in italics.

    bq. This "bq." at the beginning of a paragraph, flush with the left hand side and with a space after it, is the code to indent one paragraph of text as a block quote.

    To add a live URL, "Text to display":http://windsofchange.net/ (no spaces between) will show up as Text to display. Always use this for links - otherwise you will screw up the columns on our main blog page.

    Finally, note that a constant onslaught of Trackback spams from auto-generated blogspot blogs has forced Winds to ban the blogspot.com domain from use in comments or trackbacks. If you host on blogspot, consider moving; otherwise, the complaints need to be directed at Google not us.










    Archives By Category
    -FEATURES: 48 Ways to Wisdom (24)
    -FEATURES: Diaries & Roundups (10)
    -FEATURES: Military Transformation Uplink (12)
    -FEATURES: New Energy Currents (20)
    -FEATURES: Reader Highlights (2)
    -FEATURES: Regional Briefings (166)
    -FEATURES: Sufi Wisdom (158)
    -FEATURES: The Bard's Breath (32)
    -FEATURES: Winds of Discovery (6)
    -FEATURES: Winds of War [WoT] (444)
    4 HA: 4th-Gen Warfare (102)
    4 HA: al-Qaeda (159)
    4 HA: Crime, Organized (26)
    4 HA: Evil Exists (110)
    4 HA: Intelligence/Spycraft (100)
    4 HA: Military (519)
    4 HA: Nukes, Poisons, Germs (135)
    4 HA: Statecraft (29)
    4 HA: War on Terror articles (705)
    Best Of... (179)
    BIZ: Business & Organizations (130)
    BIZ: Economics (94)
    BIZ: Energy (69)
    CIVIS (230)
    CIVIS: Copyright Wars (25)
    CIVIS: Drug Wars (18)
    CIVIS: Edu-Kooks (76)
    CIVIS: Free Societies (280)
    CIVIS: Hall of Shame (162)
    CIVIS: Hatred Rising (114)
    CIVIS: Journalism & Media (393)
    CIVIS: Spirit of America.NET (31)
    CIVIS: War Within the West (308)
    COLUMNISTS: M. Simon (13)
    COLUMNISTS: Tarek Heggy (33)
    GEO: Afghanistan (78)
    GEO: Africa (101)
    GEO: Asia (115)
    GEO: Aussies & Kiwis (19)
    GEO: Canada (68)
    GEO: China (86)
    GEO: Europe (170)
    GEO: France (71)
    GEO: India-Pakistan (112)
    GEO: Iran (223)
    GEO: Iraq (952)
    GEO: Israel (241)
    GEO: Koreas (64)
    GEO: Latin America (63)
    GEO: Middle East (251)
    GEO: Russia (74)
    GEO: Saudi Arabia (64)
    GEO: Sudan (36)
    GEO: U.K. (70)
    GEO: U.N. (60)
    GEO: U.S. of A (501)
    HUMANITY (88)
    HUMANITY: Art & Culture (156)
    HUMANITY: Art - Music (31)
    HUMANITY: Art - Poetry (6)
    HUMANITY: Christianity (52)
    HUMANITY: Heroes & Achievements (226)
    HUMANITY: History (122)
    HUMANITY: Islam (181)
    HUMANITY: Judaism (135)
    HUMANITY: Love (31)
    HUMANITY: Philosophy (47)
    HUMANITY: Spirituality & Religion (71)
    HUMANITY: Zen & Buddhism (28)
    Humour (194)
    Misc. (42)
    NET: Blogosphere (390)
    NET: Cyber-Security (16)
    NET: Grid Computing (3)
    NET: Spam (24)
    NET: The Internet (35)
    NET: The Open Source Meme (17)
    Personal (183)
    SCI-TECH: Biotech & Medical (83)
    SCI-TECH: Eco-tech (78)
    SCI-TECH: Nanotech (27)
    SCI-TECH: Science (111)
    SCI-TECH: Space (75)
    SCI-TECH: Technology (140)
    SPORTS (45)
    SPORTS: Baseball (75)
    Trends (64)
    USA: America Catch-all (18)
    USA: Anti-Americanism (6)
    USA: California Politics (4)
    USA: Conservatives & GOP (30)
    USA: Dem Party Renewal (70)
    USA: Domestic Issues (50)
    USA: Elections (71)
    USA: Grand Strategy (15)
    USA: Homeland Security (105)
    VictoryPAC (3)
    Winds of Change.NET (48)

    Archives by Date
    Winds Blogroll


    Powered by:
    LighTTPD web server
    Ubuntu Linux
    Movable Type
    Hosted by Pixelgate
    Support VictoryPAC
    Recent Entries

    Support Winds of Change.NET!


    Your support & assistance is greatly appreciated, and makes a difference!
    The Winds Crew:

    Town Founder:
    Joe Katzman
    joe {at} windsofchange. net
    Joe's Normblog Interview

    Left-Hand Man:
    Marc 'Armed Liberal' Danziger
    armed {at} windsofchange. net
    A.L.'s Normblog Interview

    Other Winds Marshals
    'AMac', aka. Marshal Festus (AMac@...)
    Robin "Straight Shooter" Burk
    'Cicero', aka. The Quiet Man (cicero@...)
    David Blue (david.blue@...)
    'Lewy14', aka. Marshal Leroy (lewy14@...)
    'Nortius Maximus', aka. Big Tuna (nortius.maximus@...)

    Other Regulars
    'Callimachus' (callimachus@...)
    'Demosophist' (demosophist@...)
    Rev./Maj. Donald Sensing
    'Molon Labe' (molon.labe@...)
    'Neo Neo-Con'
    Tarek Heggy (tarek@...)

    Semi-Active:
    Arthur Chrenkoff
    'Gabriel Gonzalez' (in Paris)
    Tim Oren (tim@...)
    Trent Telenko (trent@...)

    Posting Affiliates
    Athena: Terrorism Unveiled
    Chester: The Adventures of Chester
    Dave Schuler: The Glittering Eye
    Grim: Grim's Lair et. al. Joel Gaines [Russia]
    Michael Totten
    MILblogging.com: The MilBlogs directory
    Murdoc [Military]
    Situational Awareness team [Military]
    Nathan Hamm [Central Asia]
    Randy Paul [Latin America]
    Robert Koehler [Koreas]
    Robi Sen [India & S. Asia]
    Nitin Pai [India & S. Asia]
    Simon [China & E. Asia]
    Yehudit: Kesher Talk

    Regular Topic Briefings:
    Andrew Olmsted [Iraq Weekly]
    Joel Gaines [Iraq Weekly]
    Security Watchtower [GWoT Mon.]
    Peace Like A River [GWoT Mon.]
    Colt [GWoT Thu.]
    John Atkinson [Alternative Energy]
    Peter Wolfgang [Alternative Energy]
    Omri Ceren [Hatewatch]

    Emeritus:
    Adil Farooq (adil@...)
    Celeste Bilby (celeste@...)
    Dan Darling
    Gary Farber (gary@...)
    Hossein Derakhshan (hoder@...)
    T.L. James (tljames@...)
    Robin Burk (robin@...)


    Winds of Change.NET Blogkids & Affiliates

    ·
    The Argus: covering Central Asia
    · Canis Iratus: Glen Wishard
    · Correct-Amundo: Tech & society
    · Discarded Lies: Ev & Zorkie
    · The Flying Kiwi: Donovan Janus
    · The Glittering Eye: Dave Schuler
    · Gumptionology: Nortius Maximus
    · Hot Needle of Inquiry: 'Jinnderella'
    · Laughing Wolf: C. Blake Powers
    · Out The Mazoo: 'Mazoo'
    · Power and Control: M. Simon
    · Praktike's Place: 'Praktike'
    · Random Probabilities: Robin Burk
    · Siberian Light: covering Russia
    · The Spirit of Man

    · Good News From the Front
    · WATCH/: covering the war on terror

    Archives By Category
    -FEATURES: 48 Ways to Wisdom (24)
    -FEATURES: Diaries & Roundups (10)
    -FEATURES: Military Transformation Uplink (12)
    -FEATURES: New Energy Currents (20)
    -FEATURES: Reader Highlights (2)
    -FEATURES: Regional Briefings (166)
    -FEATURES: Sufi Wisdom (158)
    -FEATURES: The Bard's Breath (32)
    -FEATURES: Winds of Discovery (6)
    -FEATURES: Winds of War [WoT] (444)
    4 HA: 4th-Gen Warfare (102)
    4 HA: al-Qaeda (159)
    4 HA: Crime, Organized (26)
    4 HA: Evil Exists (110)
    4 HA: Intelligence/Spycraft (100)
    4 HA: Military (519)
    4 HA: Nukes, Poisons, Germs (135)
    4 HA: Statecraft (29)
    4 HA: War on Terror articles (705)
    Best Of... (179)
    BIZ: Business & Organizations (130)
    BIZ: Economics (94)
    BIZ: Energy (69)
    CIVIS (230)
    CIVIS: Copyright Wars (25)
    CIVIS: Drug Wars (18)
    CIVIS: Edu-Kooks (76)
    CIVIS: Free Societies (280)
    CIVIS: Hall of Shame (162)
    CIVIS: Hatred Rising (114)
    CIVIS: Journalism & Media (393)
    CIVIS: Spirit of America.NET (31)
    CIVIS: War Within the West (308)
    COLUMNISTS: M. Simon (13)
    COLUMNISTS: Tarek Heggy (33)
    GEO: Afghanistan (78)
    GEO: Africa (101)
    GEO: Asia (115)
    GEO: Aussies & Kiwis (19)
    GEO: Canada (68)
    GEO: China (86)
    GEO: Europe (170)
    GEO: France (71)
    GEO: India-Pakistan (112)
    GEO: Iran (223)
    GEO: Iraq (952)
    GEO: Israel (241)
    GEO: Koreas (64)
    GEO: Latin America (63)
    GEO: Middle East (251)
    GEO: Russia (74)
    GEO: Saudi Arabia (64)
    GEO: Sudan (36)
    GEO: U.K. (70)
    GEO: U.N. (60)
    GEO: U.S. of A (501)
    HUMANITY (88)
    HUMANITY: Art & Culture (156)
    HUMANITY: Art - Music (31)
    HUMANITY: Art - Poetry (6)
    HUMANITY: Christianity (52)
    HUMANITY: Heroes & Achievements (226)
    HUMANITY: History (122)
    HUMANITY: Islam (181)
    HUMANITY: Judaism (135)
    HUMANITY: Love (31)
    HUMANITY: Philosophy (47)
    HUMANITY: Spirituality & Religion (71)
    HUMANITY: Zen & Buddhism (28)
    Humour (194)
    Misc. (42)
    NET: Blogosphere (390)
    NET: Cyber-Security (16)
    NET: Grid Computing (3)
    NET: Spam (24)
    NET: The Internet (35)
    NET: The Open Source Meme (17)
    Personal (183)
    SCI-TECH: Biotech & Medical (83)
    SCI-TECH: Eco-tech (78)
    SCI-TECH: Nanotech (27)
    SCI-TECH: Science (111)
    SCI-TECH: Space (75)
    SCI-TECH: Technology (140)
    SPORTS (45)
    SPORTS: Baseball (75)
    Trends (64)
    USA: America Catch-all (18)
    USA: Anti-Americanism (6)
    USA: California Politics (4)
    USA: Conservatives & GOP (30)
    USA: Dem Party Renewal (70)
    USA: Domestic Issues (50)
    USA: Elections (71)
    USA: Grand Strategy (15)
    USA: Homeland Security (105)
    VictoryPAC (3)
    Winds of Change.NET (48)

    Archives by Date
    Winds Blogroll


    Powered by:
    LighTTPD web server
    Ubuntu Linux
    Movable Type
    Hosted by Pixelgate